Dumbest Graph of the Day

FT Alphaville says: Credit from equity. It’s not a new concept but haven’t yet seen it represented as neatly as in this graph.
True, new totally idiotic concept, comparing a credit spread to the price level of an equity index from Bank of America no less…
Whoever wrote this report should be fired on the spot.

Posted by jck at 4:32 am EST on April 2nd, 2008 |

Trackback URI | Comments RSS

10 Responses to “ Dumbest Graph of the Day ”

  • # 1 Noel Says:

    Would you agree it would have been valid to compare equity vol to credit spread?

  • # 2 jck Says:

    Noel:
    Ideally, I would compare the credit spread to the equity risk premium.
    It used to be one of my pet theories that credit spreads and equity volatilty were closely linked, but this has clearly been falsified over the past year or so. Look at Lehman.

  • # 3 The Epicurean Dealmaker Says:

    Personally, I’ve always thought the graph comparing the ABX index to Al Gore’s waistline was particularly illuminating.

    I wonder how many other such gems are lurking in the 48-page BofA report.

  • # 4 yi Says:

    Can we change the title to “dumbest post by Alea of the day”? You think the number one ranked credit strategist on Wall Street should be fired over a graph. Even if you think the premise doesn’t fly, you think he should be FIRED over a graph? Really?

    I suppose you think folks think more highly of your own opinions? Which is why you run a blog on the market, rather than raking in millions of dollars a year putting your money where your mouth is.

  • # 5 yi Says:

    Either your comment feature is busted or its set to only accept comments that agree with you

  • # 6 jck Says:

    yi:
    My comment feature is not busted, but it is set to minimize spam and obnoxious behavior. If you have something clever to say, try a better address than “buggeroff@nocom.”
    If you don’t like the blog, get lost.

  • # 7 barry Says:

    JCK

    I think the equity/credit link was busted by the FED. Bond holders now have two sources of protection. They can claim the assets of the equity holders and they can also put their assets to the FED.

  • # 8 jck Says:

    barry:
    could be, we also had a big move towards lower real rates.

  • # 9 bh Says:

    In the Black-Scholes-Merton contingent claims analysis equity and credit spreads bonds are treated as long/short put options on the assets of the firm. Plotting a proxy for asset value (equity index levels) vs spreads (option values)? Yeah, what a ridiculous idea.

  • # 10 jck Says:

    bh:
    indeed plotting an asset value against a derivative is pretty ridiculous, it yields no information unless you find it surprising that “put” options go up when prices go down.

  • Leave a Reply

    contact

    jck [at]

    aleablog [dot] com


    © 2008 Alea | Powered by Wordpress


    E-mail It